For photos from the Meadowlands contact Lisaphoto@playmeadowlands.com

Thursday, November 5, 2015

Who's Watching Those Rescuing America's Race Horses?

If you are concerned about the well-being of off the track racehorses or for that fact, any horse seeking a new career and you are on social media, you eventually will come across postings which accuse individuals and/ or groups of not taking care of their charges.  Sometimes they may be accused of starving horses; sometimes they are blamed for amishing their charges, which is another divisive issue in itself, a topic for another time.

Usually once the first salvo is fired, it is only a matter of time until the person/group responds defending themselves from the accusations, the start of the back and forth of accusations and defenses which will get people taking sides, often  based on who they may trust   Heaven forbid you trust both parties; your head probably will spin more than Reagan's head did in The Exorcist.  

Clearly both sides can't be right.  Someone either has higher standards than the other group or someone is lying.  Why would someone lie you may ask?

As typically is the case, m-o-n-e-y.  The number of donors and the amount of money available for horse rescue is limited.  Now let me make it perfectly clear, I am not taking sides in any on-going disputes.  Sometime a charge may be to discredit a group for the benefit of their own group, sometimes the charges are true.

Unfortunately, unless you live down the road from the two groups, you won't know what the real story is. What is needed is a way to help the donor properly assess the situation regarding the rescues they are considering supporting.  For the thoroughbred, the Thoroughbred Aftercare Alliance (TAA) offers accreditation of rescues which meet their standards, making them eligible for funding from the TAA.  Of course, supporters of thoroughbred rescue may use the accreditation in determining which groups they wish to support.

Alas, if you are a supporter of the standardbred, there is no Standardbred Aftercare Alliance, so it is 'donor beware' of whom you support.  While there is no fool proof method of determining who to support, I offer the following suggestions.


  1. Know the type of rescue it is.  Do they take in surrenders, go to the sales and buy horses, and/or do they deal with brokers in rescuing horses?  While I avoid those who try to rescue broker horses due to the potential of the rescue being used as a means for brokers to sell horses at a handsome profit, the point is support a rescue which meets your philosophical/ethical approach.
  2. Does the rescue welcome visitors?  Sure, there may be times when they can't accept visitors but they should be able to accommodate you and allow you to see their rescues.  If you keep getting excuses, it is not the rescue for you and a major red flag.
  3. Does the rescue make adopters fill out an application and check applicants or does the horse go to the first person who has the money?
  4. Does the rescue require adopters to file periodic reports?  Do they maintain ownership of the horse and take back horses when an adoption doesn't work out or do they allow the horse to once again become at risk?
  5. Does the rescue ban the breeding of any of their horses as part of their contract?
  6. How long has the rescue been operating?  If more than two years old, and it has not gotten its tax exempt status, 501(c)3, beware.  While having this tax exempt status is no guarantee the organizations is legitimate, being a 501(c)3 means the rescue is not for profit.  Lack of the 501(c)3 status means someone can legally be making money running the rescue, something which should raise a red flag.  Don't get me wrong, a rescue with a 501(c)3 status can violate the rules, but if caught, they may face the music from the IRS and prosecutors.
  7. If a 501(c)3, they should make their most recent form 990 available for review either on their website or on a site such as Charity Navigator.  If the group has recently become 501(c)3, it may take a little time for the rescue to get their act together with regards to this but if they have been around any length of time, the 990 is readily available.  Not online?  Ask them to send you their most recent 990.  If form 990 is not available, it's a red flag (realize there may be a one year delay on getting the form 990 posted.
  8. Are they accredited in any way?  Realistically, if they are a small rescue, they may not have the ability or time to achieve accreditation, but if they are a larger rescue and been around awhile, they should be accredited by an organization such as the Global Federation of Animal Sanctuaries.  Accreditation is another check on the validity of the organization.
This is not an all or none list.  A rescue may not meet all of these items (not that this is a definitive list) but if they fail enough of these items, you may want to look elsewhere.  

An accreditation from a group like the TAA would be the best solution in determining which rescues are best but failing that, it is up to you to do the work to give you the best chance of your hard earned dollars going to valid rescues.  While it is unlikely the standardbred industry will form a similar alliance in the foreseeable future, perhaps the standardbred industry could contract with the TAA to perform such a review of standardbred rescues.

Friday, October 30, 2015

A Note for Our Canadian Readers

I am talking to you.  It would be nice if you were a harness racing 'only' fan, but we know a good number of you are planning to wager on the Breeders Cup this weekend.  Well, you are going to do what you want to do but if you are planning on playing the Breeders Cup races this weekend and live in Canada, consider this press release from the Horse Players Association of North America (HANA).


Keeneland's Breeders' Cup Takeout Is Arbitrarily Increased for Customers North of the Border

HANA Calls For Canadian Pari-Mutuel Agency, Woodbine to Respond to Customer Pricing Concerns
The Woodbine Entertainment Group, the entity which Canadian horseplayers, through live, OTB and Internet, wager on horse racing, has announced the betting menu for the 2015 Breeders' Cup has been significantly changed.

Takeout rates for the 19% trifecta, superfecta and pick 3 pools at Keeneland have been increased to 27%, place and show from 16% to 18%, and two horses exotics, super high 5, pick 4 and 5, from 19% to 20%. Only win and the pick 6 were left the same as the host track.

"Woodbine drew the ire of many this spring when they created a new pick 5 with 25% takeout, which was well above the industry standard of 15%. Now in the fall we see Breeders' Cup takeouts have been massively increased. We at the Horseplayers' Association of North America call on Woodbine and the Canadian Pari-mutuel Agency (CPMA) to address these issues. These are policies that are driving more and more horseplayers to other games of skill, further eroding horse racing's betting customer base, and hurting the entire industry," said Horseplayers Association of North America President Jeff Platt.

"According to their release, Woodbine said they are instituting this new measure in part because of "significant taxes" that are applied on wagers that are not seen in the US. The truth of the matter is, in Canada, and Ontario, only 0.5% of every dollar wagered goes to the provincial government, with 0.8% to the federal government. Simulcast deals made between Woodbine and horsemen groups which penalize horseplayers are on them, not on the customer, and should've been updated long ago to reflect the 21st century simulcast market," added Platt.

In Canada, horseplayers cannot patronize a competitor this weekend to escape the high takeouts and lower payoffs. Woodbine has a monopoly on pari-mutuel horse racing wagering in the country.

For more information please contact info@hanaweb.org

 

Well, if you still plan to reward WEG for the gouging of the horseplayer on the Breeders Cup, good luck to you.  If, on the other hand you refuse to reward WEG for their actions,  let me offer you a few alternatives.  At Hoosier Park, you have a bundle of stakdes races tonight including a match up of Jiggle It Wiggleit and Freaky Feet Pete and on Saturday night, there are the two Kindergarten stakes races at Vernon Downs, the final RUS event of the season at Flamboro Downs, and Century Downs hosts the Alberta Sires Stakes.

Thursday, October 29, 2015

Forest City Sale


The Forest City Sale at the Western Fair District in London, Ontario has mimicked the ups and downs of the harness racing game in that province for the last several years. In 2011, when the Ontario Sire Stakes program was humming along, 263 yearlings averaged more than $18,000. The following year, when the wheels started to fall off the cart, the average dropped more than 40% to $10,500. The fillies averaged only $8,000. As the doomsday scenario engineered by the politicians was reversed, things improved. In 2013 the average increased to $13,524, and last year it rose once more to $15,294. And this year it jumped again, to $23,207.

The number of yearlings offered has fallen off by close to half since 2011; that is what’s troubling. The fact that the top sale was a colt by Camluck, who passed in August at age 28, goes to the heart of the matter. His eight colts, a gelding and six fillies averaged $33,400. Eleven by new kid on the block, Big Jim, averaged just a thousand dollars more. There’s a dearth of new blood. The landscape will change dramatically in 2017, which is when first Ontario crops by Royalty For Life, Archangel, E L Titan, Betterthancheddar, Sunfire Blue Chip and Sunshine Beach hit the sales ring. There will also be another Bettor’s Delight crop available.

With Muscle Mass, Dewey, and Manofmanymissions having left the province, there’s a gap to fill. It’s going to take time to regenerate production. The Canadian dollar is weak and many breeders, horsemen and owners folded their tents during the equine recession.

The paucity of high end product is also an issue at this sale. Thirteen Kadabras sold at Lexington and twenty will be available in Harrisburg. Seven averaged $40,000 at the Canadian Yearling Sale, with fillies going for $70,000 and $72,000.  There weren’t any at Forest City. Eleven by Sportswriter sold at Lexington and ten will be for sale in Harrisburg. Four averaged $30,000 at the CYS. A pair sold for $8,000 each at Western Fair.

Sixteen-tear-old Mach Three has been very consistent over the years. Sixteen averaged $32,000 in 2011; seven averaged $28,000 the following year when the bottom caved and the gross was off by $2.1 million; 13 averaged $18,577 in 2013; another 13 averaged more than $31,000 last year; and ten averaged $34,600 this year. A dozen averaged more than $38,000 at the CYS. With the exception of 2013 he’s kept his average up in the $30,000 range. Mach Three has never come close to duplicating SBSW, a member of his second crop, and he keeps a low profile on the Grand Circuit, but the likes of Solar Sister, Wrangler Magic, Physicallyinclined and Mr Carrots keep sweeping up that OSS dough.

Shadow Play, who had a successful first crop featuring Arthur Blue Chip, Lady Shadow, Skippin By and Play It Again Sam, regressed somewhat his sophomore season, thanks in no small part to Sportswriter. But two-year-old Nvestment Bluechip  and three-year-olds Tessa Seelster and Cast No Shadow had good years in the OSS. He averaged $27,406 for 7 colts and 9 fillies sold at Forest City. A filly sold for 60 and another for 58. Eight averaged $30,000 at the CYS. His first crop averaged less than $12,000 in 2012; he made a big jump to $23,393 the following year; last year, as a result of his domination by Sportswriter in the OSS, he fell back 33% to $15,556.  Bettor’s Delight, Sportswriter and Mach Three are a problem for him.

Badlands Hanover keeps plugging away. The nineteen-year-old son of Western Hanover finished the year third overall in the OSS, with successful years from Ms Mac N Cheese, Semi Automatic and Free Show. His average dropped from $22,000 in 2011 to $12,000 in 2012 and $8,400 the following year. In 2014 he inched up to $9,200 for 14 sold, with a high of $25,000. This year he jumped 40% to $15,429 for 14 sold, again with a high of $25,000. His fee was reduced $1,500 to $3,500 in 2015.

Daylon Magician, who failed his fertility test in 2011 and has been back and forth, sold a colt for $65,000 and another for $50,000. Another colt brought $9,000 at the CYS. He bred 31 mares two years ago with limited success. None sold at the Canadian Yearling Sale or Lexington Selected. And none will sell in Harrisburg. He’s the best son of Kadabra, who has produced no siring sons. Tara Hills Stud, which stands Daylon, when his off and on breeding career is on, as well as Kadabra, Sportswriter and Mach Three, said their breeding numbers were off by half in 2013. That is showing up at this year’s sales.

Big Jim’s first crop was ok; his fillies finished fourth in the OSS and his colts eighth. Four of the eleven he sold at Forest City topped $50,000. His $34,355 average was almost double what it was last year for that first crop. At that time 78% of his Forest City offering failed to top $15,000, and only one topped $25,000. This time nine of the eleven beat $15,000 and a half dozen topped $25,000. Only two sold at the Canadian Yearling Sale, a filly for $29,000 and a gelding for $3,500.

The trotting sires represented at the sale didn’t stand out. The lone exception was Manofmanymissions, the sire of Bluegrass and ISS winner, Celebrity Eventsy. He stood in Ontario for two years, before relocating to Ohio. This is his last Ontario crop. A half dozen averaged $30,750, with a high of $63,000 and all but one topping $20,000.

Joe FitrzGerald

Wednesday, October 28, 2015

Late to the Party but Better Later Than Never

*It took a long time, but finally the FSBOA has joined United Florida Horsemen and the No Decoupling Campaign as the threat of the Florida legislature's approval of Decoupling ( the elimination of the requirement of racinos to have live racing) grows.

Here is the press release:


NoDecoupling Masthead Standardbred
Harness Driver
"Our established businesses and employees should be more important to Florida than out-of-state companies lured with taxpayer funds that--more often than not--don't fulfill their job creation promises," Florida's Harness Horsemen say.  "It's time Florida recognize us as voters, taxpayers, citizens and businesspeople worth keeping."

Florida Standardbred Breeders and Owners Association Joins NoDecoupling.com

With marketing resources, fan-friendly facilities and competitive opportunities for harness horsemen seemingly disappearing by the day in Florida, theFlorida Standardbred Breeders and Owners Association (FSBOA) joined the NoDecoupling.com campaign this week to further solidify horsemen's unified voice in state-level legislative issues.
NoDecoupling.com comprises the Florida Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association, the Florida Quarter Horse Racing Association, the Florida Quarter Horse Breeders' and Owners Association and their respective national "parents," the National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association, the American Quarter Horse Association and now, U.S. Trotting. Altogether, NoDecoupling.com represents over 350,000 horsemen nationwide and over 10,000 in Florida alone.
Voraciously passionate about their sport, Florida's harness horsemen are frustrated and tired of being pigeonholed, where the ability for established patrons and potential fans to watch and enjoy harness racing has literally been cordoned off to such a tight and unpleasant space that horsemen are losing hope of creating or even maintaining their audience in Florida.
"If decoupling passes, harness racing in Florida would likely be headed toward extinction," FSBOA President and Executive Director Joe Pennacchio predicts. "Book it."
What people say about harness racing and what the harness horsemen see are two different things. The presumption that decoupling is a "done deal." The insistence that harness racing is dying while, in reality, virtually every aspect of horsemen's once-thriving business seems to have been maneuvered into hopelessness.
"Across South Florida, shiny new casinos beckon slot machine players with air conditioning, service and new amenities, while harness racing fans must sweat it out with no shelter and bare-bones amenities," Pennacchio explains. "Some casino facility owners seem to be already preparing for decoupling by making customers' pari-mutuel experience as miserable as possible. It's not exactly an equation that helps to grow, much less restore a market."
"Our established businesses and employees should be more important to Florida than out-of-state companies lured with taxpayer funds that--more often than not--don't fulfill their job creation promises," Pennacchio adds. "It's time Florida recognize our horsemen as voters, taxpayers, citizens and businesspeople worth keeping."
Known as "Standardbreds," harness racing horses descend from Colonial times before automobiles when the spirit of competition would strike two horse and buggy drivers in transit. Much like drag racers give the classic "thumbs up," the drivers of yesteryear would enjoy an impromptu matchup. Soon, the buggy races became organized and the sport of Standardbred or "harness" racing began.
Although their style is all different, it's horsemen's love of the sport and their animals that bonds Florida's Thoroughbred, American Quarter Horse and Standardbred owners, trainers and breeders. On the business side, their futures are inextricably linked in the complex wagering world of Interstate and Inter-Track Simulcasting.
The NoDecoupling.com campaign seeks to educate Florida Legislators about how horse racing of all kinds provides greater and more extensive economic impact than stand-alone casinos, particularly because of the cost and labor involved in training and maintaining a racehorse. Decoupling would immediately decrease purses, making Florida the loser against other, more horse racing-friendly states that recognize the sport's superior economic benefits.

www.NoDecoupling.com



As you can see, standardbred racing is so poorly known in Florida, the press release needed to explain what harness racing racing is.  There is no sense in rehashing why the FSBOA didn't join with the UFH coalition until now; it is better late than never. With only one venue in Florida, decoupling slots with racing at Pompano Park would be the end of the sport in Florida, likely closing up the multiple training facilities (shame on anyone who would winter train in a state where the sport had been killed off).


You may be asking why should you care about what goes on Florida?  The moment decoupling were to occur in a state such as the home to Gulfstream, Hialeah, and Tampa Downs, casino companies owning harness and thoroughbred tracks will have their lobbyists beating down the door in other racing legislatures to decouple racing there.

It is good to see the USTA get involved in this battle, but it would be helpful if other horsemen groups of various breeds were to look past their parochial interests and consider the interests of Florida horsemen their own.

Tuesday, October 27, 2015

Kentucky Racing and State Cutbacks

Kentucky has issued harness dates for 2016 and The Red Mile, even with Instant Racing days will have its usual 32 days of racing, including the two week Grand Circuit Meet.  In addition, Bluegrass Downs has been given a total of 15 days.  A robust (note sarcasm) of 47 days of harness racing in Kentucky.

But wait, Thunder Ridge has been given 21 conditional race dates assuming it can pay its debts to three of Kentucky's thoroughbred tracks or explain to the commission how it plans to repay it.  Astute followers of Kentucky racing, know this year's meet was to be the final year of racing in Prestonburg as their license was to be sold to Keenland for a quarter horse track; a deal which has not closed yet.  Of course, the deal can be finalized which makes issuing harness dates to Thunder Ridge moot.

The one amusing thing at this meeting was the commissions concern that it costs more to regulate a day or racing at Thunder Ridge than is wagered, assuming anyone wagers on the day's card.  Did they only realize it now?   After all Thunder Ridge is the only track a $2(a day) bettor would be considered a whale.  While I realize harness horsemen need all the racing dates they can in Kentucky, how the KHRC has allowed Thunder Ridge to operate as long as it has is bewildering.


States are demanding racing pick up more of its own costs instead of the state paying the expenses.  In New York State, the state will no longer pay for drug testing of claimed horses, an expense of  $150 per horse each time they are claimed.  If successful claimants want a horse tested for drugs, they will need to shoulder the cost.  While this should not be problematic for horsemen racing at Yonkers, the $150 expense may be a deterrent for testing at the upstate tracks in the bottom classes as horsemen may skip the testing since they operate on such a thin margin.  What's important about testing claimed horses?  A successful claimant may void the claim should a horse come up positive.


Passing on the cost of drug testing from the state to the tracks is what is behind the threatened shut down of horse racing in Pennsylvania.  As the state is in the middle of a budget impasse, the fund which regulates racing will run out as the state annually pays $20 million in expenses but receives on $11 million from racing; the $9 million gap is what is spend on drug testing.  If an agreement with the tracks to take over the cost is not reached by the end of the week, the PHRC is planning on issuing a notice of shutdown on Friday.   In addition, there is legislation working its way through the legislature which will require racing to pay for its own drug testing.


Some other notes and observations:  It is reported no one from the Meadowlands management was a t the Breeders Crown this past weekend.  While there is no requirement someone must attend, it is a bad visual if no one from East Rutherford was in attendance.  What a great story coming out of the Breeders Crown with Jimmy Takter winning six of the twelve crown races.  Unfortunately, as good as this was for Team Takter, it also highlights the problem in racing with not enough owners in the sport which would result in horses being handed over to other conditioners.  With more owners, other qualified trainers may have a chance to go against the Takter juggernaut.  We have been following how Share The Delight's off-spring have performed in the United Kingdom and Ireland.  Unfortunately, it seem Share The Delight  has not succeeded in the stallion shed up to now.